I use a very cheap, all-natural eye-make up remover: Olive Oil!
I LOVE olive oil for more than just cooking. It's great for your hair too. When I need a little shine, I'll rub just a little on my palms and lightly rub my hands down the "canopy" of my head!
I especially love olive oil for an eye make up remover because it works amazingly! I mean amazingly! Just a tiny drop on a cotton ball and one swipe over the eyelids and my eyes are free of make up!
I wouldn't recommend this if you have oily skin, naturally. But those who have normal/combination or dry skin this might be a nice, alternative to a store bought, chemical laden remover!